2025 NFL Draft Grades: Analyzing the Best Picks and Potential Busts by The Athletic

Nashville, Tennessee – The first round of the 2025 NFL Draft brought significant excitement, as teams across the league made crucial decisions to shape their futures. The Athletic’s pick-by-pick grades offer insight into which teams may have secured potential stars and which general managers might have some regrets down the line.

Grades for each pick were provided by Scott Dochterman for odd-numbered selections and Nick Baumgardner for even-numbered picks. The analysis took into account various factors such as pick value, trade cost, available prospects, and team needs.

The Tennessee Titans kicked off the draft by selecting quarterback Cam Ward from Miami, filling a significant need. Ward’s talent and grit make him a promising choice to lead the team. The Jacksonville Jaguars made a strategic move by acquiring Travis Hunter, a versatile player who can excel at cornerback and wide receiver.

The New York Giants opted for Abdul Carter, an edge rusher from Penn State, showcasing a commitment to selecting the best player available rather than drafting for immediate needs. The New England Patriots secured offensive lineman Will Campbell from LSU, a safe pick to bolster their rebuilding efforts around a young quarterback.

The Cleveland Browns added Mason Graham, a powerful interior defender from Michigan, to enhance their run defense. The Las Vegas Raiders found a gem in Ashton Jeanty, a dynamic running back from Boise State with the potential to make a significant impact in the league.

The New York Jets addressed their offensive line by selecting Armand Membou from Missouri, adding depth to protect their quarterback. The Carolina Panthers strengthened their receiving corps with Tetairoa McMillan from Arizona, a reliable target with exceptional ball skills.

Throughout the first round, teams made strategic picks to address immediate needs and build for the future. Each selection carries expectations and possibilities as these young athletes embark on their NFL journeys.

The draft day excitement continued with each team making strategic moves to secure talent and build competitive rosters for the upcoming season. As the rookie class transitions to the professional stage, the true impact of these selections will unfold in the seasons to come.