London, England — Actor John Lithgow is addressing concerns surrounding his portrayal of Albus Dumbledore in the upcoming “Harry Potter” series for HBO, particularly in light of controversies involving series creator J.K. Rowling. As an executive producer on the show, Rowling has faced backlash for her remarks on transgender issues, prompting discussion among fans about the implications of her involvement.
In a recent interview with The Times, Lithgow revealed that he has been urged by friends and fans to reconsider his decision to accept the role. He shared a poignant exchange he had with a close friend, a mother of a transgender child, who expressed her concerns in the form of an article titled “An Open Letter to John Lithgow: Please Walk Away From Harry Potter.”
Lithgow reflected on the enormity of his decision, acknowledging the role’s significance as potentially his last major project. “It’s an eight-year commitment, and I was contemplating my career and what this role means at this stage,” he stated. Despite the challenges, he emphasized that the criticism he has faced was unexpected.
When asked if the backlash affected his resolve, Lithgow remained unfazed, asserting, “Oh, heavens no.” His greater worry lies in whether “Harry Potter” fans will accept an American actor in such an iconic British role.
The actor also noted the perceived inconsistency in public outrage, questioning why he faced scrutiny for taking on the role of Dumbledore while his portrayal of Roald Dahl, whose family has acknowledged his antisemitic views, did not elicit similar backlash. “Isn’t that odd?” Lithgow remarked, highlighting the complexities of public perception.
The announcement of the series in April 2023 sparked immediate reactions, particularly toward Rowling’s involvement. HBO’s Casey Bloys addressed the concerns, stating, “J.K. is a very online conversation. … It’s nuanced and complicated. Our priority is what’s onscreen.” He emphasized the positive themes of love and acceptance at the core of the “Harry Potter” narrative.
Rowling has made several controversial statements regarding transgender women, including support for a U.K. court ruling that defines women based on biological sex. This has prompted criticism from various public figures, including John Oliver and Pedro Pascal, who have vocalized dissent against her views.
As the new series prepares to enchant a new generation, the intersection of Rowling’s comments, Lithgow’s casting, and the community’s reactions continues to fuel debate. The actor remains steadfast in his commitment to the role, eager to contribute to a story that has touched countless lives.