Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania — The Pittsburgh Pirates have parted ways with manager Derek Shelton after over five seasons in charge. His dismissal comes amid a disappointing start to the current season, prompting the organization to elevate bench coach Don Kelly as his permanent replacement.
General Manager Ben Cherington announced the decision, expressing gratitude for Shelton’s hard work and dedication to the team. “Derek’s commitment to the Pirates and our community has been commendable. However, a change was necessary to steer the team in a new direction,” Cherington stated. Shelton, who took the helm in the 2019-20 offseason, oversaw a challenging tenure marked by a combined record of 306 wins and 440 losses.
During Shelton’s time, the Pirates struggled to capitalize on their potential, peaking at just 76 wins in a season twice. Currently, the team holds a 12-26 record this year, raising concerns about their postseason aspirations. Pirates owner Bob Nutting addressed the situation, acknowledging the team’s struggles. “The start to the season has been frustrating for everyone involved. We are fully aware that improvements need to be made, and we must act quickly,” he said.
Kelly, a Pittsburgh native and former utility player, has been with the Pirates since Shelton’s hiring in 2020, serving as his right-hand man. He now steps into the managerial role without an interim tag, signaling the team’s commitment to his leadership. Nutting praised Kelly’s dedication to the franchise, asserting, “He is someone who embodies the spirit of the Pirates and is committed to helping us return to competitiveness.”
The decision to let go of Shelton has invoked mixed reactions, with some analysts suggesting that he may not have had the resources available for success. Despite the poor performance, the organization has been criticized for its reluctance to invest in free agency, raising questions about financial strategies. The Pirates have not signed a multi-year free agent contract since acquiring pitcher Ivan Nova nearly a decade ago.
Talent development remains a critical issue within the Pirates organization. While standout players like Paul Skenes have shown promise, many top prospects have yet to replicate their minor league success in the majors. Some, such as Ke’Bryan Hayes and Endy Rodriguez, have faced injuries, while others, including Nick Gonzales and Henry Davis, have struggled to make an impact.
As Kelly takes the reins, he faces the formidable task of revitalizing a team that has often found itself on the verge of improvement yet falling short. His prior experience within the organization and his connections with current players may aid in building a more cohesive unit. However, the road ahead remains steep, especially considering the Pirates’ need for foundational changes.
While the immediate focus turns to the remainder of the season, questions linger regarding the team’s long-term strategy. Kelly’s ability to navigate the complexities of the managerial position will be closely monitored as the Pirates seek to establish a new identity and bolster their chances for future success. The upcoming winter will be pivotal, as the organization evaluates both Kelly’s performance and potential avenues for growth.