Quarterback Showdown: Who Will Claim the Saints’ Crown in the Post-Derek Carr Era?

New Orleans, Louisiana—The Saints are entering a new chapter following the departure of Derek Carr, igniting a competitive atmosphere among three quarterbacks vying for the starting position. Rookie Tyler Shough and returning players Jake Haener and Spencer Rattler will all have the chance to showcase their abilities as training camps approach.

Head coach Kellen Moore expressed optimism about the three quarterbacks, noting their individual achievements that have earned them this opportunity. “We’re going to let all three of these guys roll,” he stated, affirming that each player will be given a fair shot to earn the role. As the preseason begins, Moore anticipates that one candidate will stand out as a leader.

Moore emphasized the importance of communication and leadership within a quarterback’s role. According to him, the ability to command the offense will be crucial for whoever emerges as the starter. “It’s essential for these players to take ownership,” he explained. The true test of their capabilities will come during training camp and preseason games, where they will have to operate under pressure.

Shough, who recently participated in rookie minicamp, made a favorable impression on the coaching staff. Moore described his performance during competitive seven-on-seven drills as “excellent.” Following this initial showcase, Shough is expected to integrate with veteran players as the offseason workouts continue.

While the competition heats up, there is a possibility that the Saints could look into adding a more experienced quarterback. Moore indicated that the team remains open to identifying a veteran if the right opportunity arises. This strategic awareness reflects a proactive approach to team development.

Haener, a fourth-round draft pick from 2023, gained valuable experience last season by appearing in eight games and starting once. He completed 18 of 39 passes for 226 yards, marked by one touchdown and one interception. Meanwhile, Rattler, selected in the fifth round in 2024, had a more extended stint, starting in six of the seven games he played. His stats included 130 completions out of 228 attempts, totaling 1,317 yards with four touchdowns but five interceptions.

Shough enters the team as the 40th overall pick of the 2025 draft and brings fresh energy to the roster. Moore recalls a similar scenario from his past, reflecting on his experience with Dak Prescott—a rookie who quickly transitioned to a starting role. Prescott capitalized on an unexpected opportunity and left a lasting mark on the franchise, setting a precedent for what Shough or the others might achieve.

As the Saints work to define their identity in this new era, the excitement surrounding the upcoming quarterback competition adds a layer of intrigue to the team’s preparations for the upcoming season. A pivotal phase awaits as players strive to distinguish themselves in a bid for the top spot and influence the team’s future trajectory.