Sacramento, California – A new proposal in California is stirring up controversy as it aims to limit the operations of Clear, a company offering expedited security screening services at airports across the state. The legislation, known as SB-1372, is the first of its kind in the U.S. and seeks to address equity concerns raised by critics who argue that Clear allows affluent individuals to jump ahead of others in line, bypassing TSA security checkpoints.
Clear charges its members $189 annually to verify their identities at airports, granting them access to a dedicated security lane. This service is currently available at more than 55 airports nationwide and several sports stadiums and venues. While Clear is distinct from TSA Pre-Check, many members utilize both services for added convenience.
State Senator Josh Newman, a Democrat, is sponsoring the bill and emphasizes the importance of equity in airport security. He highlights the frustration felt by travelers as Clear members are escorted to the front of TSA lines, creating a divide between those who can afford the service and those who cannot.
On the other hand, Republican Senator Janet Nguyen shares similar concerns but is not backing the bill. She acknowledges the challenges posed by Clear’s operations, especially in creating a disparity between travelers based on financial capability. Major airlines like Delta, United, Southwest, Alaska, JetBlue, and Hawaiian have also expressed opposition to the legislation, citing potential revenue losses and negative impacts on customer experience.
Supporters of the bill, including the Association of Flight Attendants-CWA and the union representing Transportation Security Officers in Oakland, Sacramento, and San Jose, are advocating for its passage. They argue that Clear’s services create longer queues and inconvenience for non-members, impacting the overall security screening process at airports.
As the debate over the proposed legislation continues, stakeholders are working to find a balance between enhancing security measures and ensuring a seamless travel experience for all passengers. The bill is scheduled to be reviewed by the California State Senate’s transportation committee, sparking further discussions on the future of airport security practices in the state.