Moscow, Idaho – A pretrial hearing on Thursday revealed challenges faced by a cellphone analyst in Bryan Kohberger’s case. The graduate student is accused of the fatal stabbings of four Idaho college students.
During the hearing, the analyst, Sy Ray, highlighted issues with law enforcement’s data collection and recordkeeping. He mentioned that not all of the cellphone data extracted from Kohberger’s phone around the time of the murders in 2022 was fully analyzed. Ray emphasized the importance of obtaining all the necessary AT&T source data to verify the accuracy of the evidence linking Kohberger to the crime scene.
Ray expressed concerns about the incomplete and inaccurate data he had reviewed so far, suggesting that the missing information could benefit Kohberger’s defense. He questioned whether the missing data was due to human error, accident, or intentional withholding.
As a former police detective with experience as an expert witness in criminal cases, Ray’s testimony shed light on the challenges faced in analyzing the evidence in the case. He also raised questions about the availability of certain data and its potential impact on the prosecution’s case against Kohberger.
In another aspect of the hearing, a lead investigator from the Moscow Police Department testified about the collection of video evidence related to a vehicle prosecutors believe Kohberger was driving at the time of the murders. The defense continues to push for the disclosure of key evidence in the discovery phase, with DNA experts expected to testify in a closed hearing.
The delays in the pretrial proceedings have pushed the trial date back to spring or summer 2025, frustrating the families of the victims. The victims, all college students living near the University of Idaho, were tragically killed in November 2022. Prosecutors have linked Kohberger to the crime scene through DNA evidence and surveillance footage. However, the defense maintains that his nighttime drives were routine and not tied to the murders.
The ongoing legal battles and delays in the case have added to the pain and frustration of the victims’ families, who seek closure and justice for their loved ones. The complexities of the evidence and legal proceedings underscore the challenges both sides face in reaching a resolution in this high-profile case in Moscow, Idaho.