Fall City Teen Pleads Not Guilty in Family Killings

Andrew Humiston faces six charges after a judge transferred the case from juvenile court and ordered him held without bail.

SEATTLE, WA — A 17-year-old accused of killing his parents and three siblings at their Fall City home pleaded not guilty Tuesday after his case was transferred to adult court, more than two years after the deadly shootings.

Andrew Humiston appeared Nov. 17 in King County Superior Court for an arraignment on five counts of aggravated first-degree murder and one count of attempted first-degree murder. He entered not-guilty pleas through his attorney. Judge Veronica Galván ordered Humiston held without bail and continued previously imposed conditions, including a no-contact order. His next court appearance is scheduled for Dec. 9.

Humiston was 15 when the killings occurred in October 2024 and is now 17. Prosecutors accuse him of killing his parents and three siblings and shooting another sibling, an 11-year-old girl who survived. Investigators have said the girl escaped from the home and went to a neighbor for help after the attack. The allegations against Humiston have not been proven at trial.

The arraignment followed Galván’s October decision to move the case out of juvenile court. The judge reached that decision after a roughly two-week hearing in which prosecutors and defense attorneys presented sharply different arguments about how the case should proceed. The transfer means Humiston will be prosecuted in the adult court system, though his age at the time of the alleged crimes can still affect how the court handles sentencing if he is convicted.

During the earlier hearing, prosecutors argued that the alleged attack was planned and involved multiple deliberate steps. Evidence described in court included allegations that Humiston obtained a firearm from a locked safe and later tried to make it appear that a younger brother was responsible for the shootings. Prosecutors have said they do not know the true motive for the killings.

Defense attorneys argued against transferring the case to adult court and described Humiston’s upbringing as isolated and abusive. They presented evidence concerning his mental health and argued that he had made progress while in juvenile detention and had significant potential for rehabilitation. Those claims were considered as part of the court’s decision over whether juvenile jurisdiction should be retained.

Galván ultimately ruled that the seriousness of the allegations, the circumstances described in the evidence and Humiston’s long-term treatment and supervision needs weighed in favor of adult jurisdiction. The judge also noted limits on how long Washington’s juvenile system can retain jurisdiction over a defendant. The ruling did not determine whether Humiston is guilty of any of the charges.

Moving the case to adult court does not automatically mean Humiston would receive an adult sentence if convicted. The King County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office has said a sentencing judge can retain discretion in cases involving defendants who committed alleged crimes as juveniles. Any sentence would depend on the outcome of the case and the court’s application of Washington law.

Tuesday’s hearing also marked a change in how Humiston could be identified publicly. During the earlier juvenile proceedings, news organizations had been restricted from showing his face or identifying him by name. After the transfer to adult court, the judge allowed his name and image to be reported.

No trial date has been announced. Local reporting indicates the case is not expected to reach trial before 2027. Humiston remains in custody as the prosecution moves forward in King County Superior Court, with the Dec. 9 hearing serving as the next confirmed step in the case.

Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.