The two suspects were ordered held for six months as prosecutors investigate the February killing of the American surfer and hotel owner.
SAN JOSÉ, COSTA RICA — Costa Rican authorities have arrested the former girlfriend of American surfer and hotel owner Kurt Van Dyke and a second suspect in connection with his February killing, a major development in a case initially reported as a violent home robbery.
Van Dyke, 66, was found dead Feb. 14 at a residence in Hone Creek, near Cahuita on Costa Rica’s Caribbean coast. Authorities identified the suspects as a 31-year-old woman with the surnames Arroyo Ramírez and a 34-year-old man with the surnames Gutiérrez Víctor. Both are being investigated for aggravated homicide and were ordered to spend six months in pretrial detention while the case proceeds.
Agents with Costa Rica’s Judicial Investigation Agency, known as the OIJ, arrested the two Nov. 12 during three raids in communities in Limón province. Investigators seized cellphones, a vehicle they suspect was used in connection with the crime and other items considered relevant to the investigation. The arrests came nearly nine months after Van Dyke’s death.
Authorities originally received an account suggesting armed men had entered the residence, restrained people inside and carried out a robbery. Arroyo Ramírez was found alive after the incident and had been described in early reports as having been restrained. Her car was also reported stolen. Investigators later found the vehicle undamaged, a discovery that became part of their inquiry into whether portions of the reported robbery had been staged.
Investigators now allege Arroyo Ramírez helped arrange for other people to enter the residence. According to reporting based on the court file, prosecutors say messages recovered during the investigation showed communications between her and a person investigators associated with Gutiérrez Víctor shortly before the attack. Those claims remain allegations under investigation and have not been established at trial.
Prosecutors allege the group intended to obtain financial information connected to Van Dyke, including PIN numbers for bank cards. Authorities say Van Dyke was assaulted when the information was not obtained. A forensic examination concluded that he died from asphyxiation caused by compression of the neck. Earlier police reports also said he had stab wounds when his body was found beneath a bed. Authorities have described the killing as part of a planned robbery rather than a random break-in.
The investigation has also focused on other people suspected of taking part in the attack. OIJ officials have said Gutiérrez Víctor allegedly entered the residence with two additional men whose identities had not been publicly established when the arrests were announced. Authorities have continued investigating their possible roles and the sequence of events surrounding Van Dyke’s death.
Van Dyke was a Santa Cruz, California, native who had lived in Costa Rica for decades and operated Hotel Puerto Viejo. He was well known in surfing circles and was sometimes called “King” in connection with the Salsa Brava surf community. He came from a prominent California surfing family: his father, Gene Van Dyke, helped pioneer surfing in Northern California, while his mother, Betty Van Dyke, was an early competitive surfer.
Peter Van Dyke, the victim’s brother, told CBS News that the family found the former girlfriend’s arrest shocking but had questions about the circumstances from the beginning. He said relatives are now focused on the legal process and expressed confidence in Costa Rican authorities after the lengthy investigation led to arrests.
A Costa Rican court ordered Arroyo Ramírez and Gutiérrez Víctor held for six months while prosecutors continue investigating the aggravated-homicide case. The detention order is not a finding of guilt, and no trial date has been publicly announced. Investigators are also continuing efforts to determine whether other suspects participated in the killing.
Author note: Last updated November 20, 2026.