Forensic genetic genealogy helped authorities identify the victim more than four years after his remains were discovered near Foresthill.
CITRUS HEIGHTS, CA — A mother and daughter have been arrested in connection with the death of a 73-year-old California man whose severed head was found in a trash bag near Foresthill more than four years ago, authorities said.
Placer County investigators identified the victim as Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., who had not been reported missing. His daughter, 45-year-old Mary Fitzmaurice, was arrested Nov. 17 on suspicion of murder, while his wife, 75-year-old Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, was arrested on suspicion of being an accessory, according to authorities. Prosecutors were reviewing the investigation to determine what formal charges should be filed.
The case began Sept. 28, 2022, when deputies were called to the Todd Valley area of Foresthill after a human head was discovered inside a trash bag. The remains were in a state that prevented investigators from immediately identifying the man, and detectives could not connect him with an existing missing-person or homicide case. The remainder of Fitzmaurice’s remains has not been located, authorities said.
Investigators pursued several methods to identify the victim. An autopsy was conducted, and forensic specialists developed a preliminary profile and an artist’s rendering. Detectives also entered DNA information into a national law enforcement database, but those efforts did not produce a match. The lack of a missing-person report further complicated efforts to determine who the man was.
A major break came after investigators turned to forensic genetic genealogy. Detectives submitted DNA for additional testing in 2024, allowing investigators to develop possible family connections through distant relatives. The FBI helped trace relatives and obtain comparison DNA, which ultimately allowed authorities to identify Fitzmaurice. The investigation then led detectives to his last known residence in Citrus Heights, where he had lived with his wife and adult daughter.
Placer County Sheriff Wayne Woo said investigators believe Mary Fitzmaurice killed her father at the family home and that she and her mother later worked together to dispose of his remains. Those claims are allegations and have not been proven in court. Authorities have not publicly established a motive, and investigators have not released a detailed account of how Fitzmaurice died or how his remains were transported to the Foresthill area.
Detectives served a search warrant Nov. 17 at the family’s Lichen Drive residence in Citrus Heights, with assistance from an FBI evidence response team. Mary and Gwenn Fitzmaurice were taken into custody later that day and booked into the South Placer Jail. Authorities said no additional remains were recovered at the home during the search.
Investigators also allege the women continued telling relatives and friends that Fitzmaurice was alive after his death. Woo said relatives were given explanations that Fitzmaurice had become reclusive and would disappear for periods of time before returning home. Authorities also said Social Security payments and a California public pension connected to Fitzmaurice continued to be received. Officials have not said that financial benefits were the motive for the killing, and Woo said the motive remained under investigation.
Placer County District Attorney Morgan Gire said prosecutors expected to pursue a murder charge against Mary Fitzmaurice for allegedly causing her father’s death. The office was also evaluating whether additional charges involving Gwenn Fitzmaurice or the collection of government and pension benefits were appropriate. The allegations contained in arrest records and statements from investigators remain subject to review by prosecutors and the courts.
The investigation involved the Placer County Sheriff’s Office Crimes Against Persons detectives and its Cold Case Investigations Team, along with the FBI, Citrus Heights Police Department and Contra Costa County Crime Lab. The Placer County Cold Case Foundation also helped fund advanced DNA testing used in the investigation. Authorities credited those efforts with turning an unidentified-remains case into an active homicide investigation more than four years after the discovery.
The case remains under investigation, and authorities have not announced the recovery of the rest of Fitzmaurice’s remains or identified a confirmed motive. The two women were expected to appear in Placer County Superior Court as prosecutors reviewed the evidence and considered formal charges.
Author note: Last updated November 19, 2026.