The latest case led to a murder charge against an Ocala man accused in the death of a woman from England.
OCALA, FL — Human remains have been found twice, 17 years apart, on the same Marion County property, with the latest discovery now tied to the homicide case of a missing woman from the United Kingdom.
The recent discovery in Marion Oaks began with a missing-person request from overseas and ended with a first-degree murder case in Florida. State agents say Sonia Exelby, 32, of Portsmouth, England, missed a scheduled flight home on Oct. 13, 2025. Four days later, investigators found remains in Marion Oaks. Authorities later identified them as Exelby and ruled her death a homicide.
The property drew renewed attention after WESH reported that remains had been found there 17 years apart. Officials have not publicly said the two discoveries are connected. The current case is being handled by the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, with help from the Marion County Sheriff’s Office. Investigators say the 2025 case moved quickly after U.K. authorities contacted FDLE through INTERPOL about a missing and endangered woman from England.
FDLE said its agents and Marion County detectives found the remains in Marion Oaks on Friday, Oct. 17, 2025. The sheriff’s office had earlier said deputies responded around 2 p.m. to the 3200 block of Southwest 27th Circle after receiving information that human remains could be on the property. After a search, the remains were recovered and FDLE continued the investigation. At the time, the sheriff’s office said there was no evidence linking the remains to an active Marion County Sheriff’s Office case.
The case changed on Nov. 17, 2025, when FDLE agents and Marion County detectives arrested Dwain Hall, 53, of Ocala, on charges of first-degree murder and kidnapping. Hall was already in jail on earlier charges involving fraudulent use of credit cards and unlawful use of a two-way communication device. FDLE said those earlier charges were tied to fraudulent use of Exelby’s credit cards. FDLE Commissioner Mark Glass said agents worked with “extraordinary speed and unwavering determination” in the case.
Investigators said Exelby had traveled to Florida after communicating with Hall online. Court records cited in local reports say Hall admitted he picked Exelby up from Gainesville Regional Airport and spent time with her before her death. Investigators also said phone records led them to disturbed soil in Marion Oaks, which was later identified as the burial site. Authorities have said Hall and Exelby had communicated for about two years before she flew to the United States.
Records described in court and local reports say investigators reviewed financial activity tied to Exelby after she arrived in Florida. A business linked to Hall, Solver Wolfs Roadside Assistance, was named in reports about attempted charges to Exelby’s cards. One payment of 905.11 pounds, about $1,190, was reported from one of Exelby’s accounts. Investigators also cited purchases that included a rope and shovel before Hall picked her up from the airport.
Hall has pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder and kidnapping. A Marion County judge has set jury selection for Nov. 16, 2026. Court TV reported that prosecutors said the only plea offer on the table was life in prison. The trial is expected to last about one week. The State Attorney’s Office for the Fifth Judicial Circuit is prosecuting the case.
The earlier discovery on the same property remains a separate point of concern in the public record. Authorities have not announced that the older case and Exelby’s death are linked, and no public filing reviewed in the current case says the two sets of remains are connected. The overlap has added unusual context to a case already involving international authorities, forensic identification and a homicide charge.
Marion County Sheriff Billy Woods said cooperation between local and state law enforcement helped bring swift action in the case. “This powerful partnership between my office and the FDLE will continue to come together and bring swift justice,” Woods said. Multiple agencies assisted, including police in Gainesville, law enforcement in Ohio, the FBI and the Hampshire and Isle of Wight Constabulary in the United Kingdom.
The case now stands in court as Hall awaits trial in Marion County. The next major milestone is jury selection, scheduled for Nov. 16, 2026, unless the court changes the date.
Author note: Last updated May 20, 2026.